I guess the second one seeing as it'll help all of us keep track of damage and for the fun conversations of Player 1: "Alright shot the blighter inbetween the eyes" Player 2: "But not after I turned him into a lead cushion".
um...It's kinda on the fence, Madmanners I believe is under the impression that we had to stop so I'm not sure...I on the other hand am looking to turn this into a traditional RPG