Writers' Guild

A community for writers of all genres to hone our craft, with monthly exercises, challenges, and collaborative writing. Open to anyone who enjoys writing!


Character Inconsistencies for the sake of Plot

 
Quote:
Originally Posted by TanaNari View Post
Also- for others' reference- I've read a few of those books. You're talking about the Thrawn series. By Timothy Zahn. Who I would consider a pretty good writer. Except every book he writes has some character with some savant like power to predict the actions of others that borders upon pre/omniscience. Quite Mary-Sue-esque in its own right. It's not terribly obvious if you only read one of his books. But. Every. Book. He. Writes. Has. That. Character.
For those not paying attention.

I've seen this kind of writing several times before (I teach students how to write decent stories, not always with any great success if they are a bit dense or close-minded) and I also teach them how to identify and avoid what I know as a Gaping Plot Hole. Any time something needs to have a
The ritual can only take place on a full moon at precisely the stroke of midnight on the summer solstice when there is also an eclipse... One second past midnight and if you've missed it your entire BBEG's plot crumbles. How easy is that for a good guy to engineer?
crazy set of conditions for an event to happen, the character acts totally out of character in order for the story to progress, 'hand of God' type incidences... all are Gaping Plot Holes.

I've read the Timothy Zahn books and I liked them, except perhaps this one where there is the problem the OP describes. To me it sounds more like the publisher decided the story had to end a certain way and the author had to comply, but that doesn't excuse the author from slipping in something earlier to make it not so jarring at the end. Maybe he was on a tight deadline and couldn't rewrite? I dunno.

If it was me, I would have made him redo the work or explain that point in the story much better, because any plot point that happens without a reason that make sense kills the suspension of disbelief as you say, and as soon as a story does that you've just lost your audience.




 

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Blog   Myth-Weavers Status